I’ve been meaning to write about him for a long time, but it was a little awkward when I was in a relationship with someone else (who I loved) to talk about the one who got away. Escaped away? Slipped away? Was pushed away?
The moment I met him I had such a visceral reaction that I was sure I hated him. This is called chemistry, I believe. I don’t think he’d said more than one word before I started rolling my eyes and sighing.
We were in this intensive first semester filmmaking class together. It was a course that prepared me for the most vicious criticism, taught me how to criticize with care and kid gloves, and I credit it for my thick skin when it comes to my creative pursuits. Every 3rd week we would show a film we had made in class. He showed his film and I was particularly brutal in class and in my written crit. I don’t know if it was that every dude in the class had been making these horribly violent sexist women-in-peril films, or that I needed some way to get under his skin, but I laid into him. So much so that I think the whole class was like, “Relax, Betty Friedan. Christ.”
And that night he called me. And he called me on it. He explained himself. And I was so taken aback that he actually listened to what I had to say, and defended himself (quite eloquently) that from that moment on I was smitten. And then in the weirdest way to get me to like you, he left this psychotic nonsense voice mail message in this half-language and a weird voice that had quite possibly the sweetest thing anyone has ever said to me in it. And we were inseparable.
And what we had together was volatile, exhausting and a little fucked up, but it was passionate and exciting and hilarious. I have known one other person in the world almost like him, and he broke my heart in a million pieces. So with this one, try as I might to let it be just fun and sexy and perverted and awesome, I pushed and pushed and finally he just had enough. And he was gone. It was almost a relief.
We’ve since made amends and I still feel that magical spark when I talk to him but I rarely see him. He and I will always be inappropriate with each other because we have no control when we’re together. He is in love with his girlfriend, and there are lines we don’t cross, but I can’t help but feel like if I hadn’t pushed quite so hard, and broken us quite so sharply, we would still be together. And that would be a problem, because I seriously can’t get anything done when I’m around him. All I want to do is play and fight and do it.
He told me today over IM that half the time he loved being with me, but the other half of the time I was so impossible to be around that he thought I hated him. I responded, “That’s because half the time I was crazy about you and the other half I was just crazy.”
And that’s the trick, isn’t it? It’s so hard to find someone you’re both crazy about and is crazy about you, but it’s harder to find someone who can also deal with your dark side. And it’s not that he couldn’t deal with it, it’s just that he brought every extreme to the surface. We were always operating at such an intense level that everything was felt like a knife, and delivered like one.
Which is partially why Louie was such a breath of fresh air. We weren’t out of our minds. But it wasn’t enough for either of us, because we just couldn’t get to that crazy place enough to keep us through the down time. We were just two people who lived together, by the end.
I’m not insane enough to believe I’ll ever find someone like him again. After all, he is still (albeit platonically) in my life and I can’t imagine having two people like him exist in my world. I would die from exhaustion. I think now I’m too old and jaded to ever have it again, anyway, much less look for it. So it’s my phantom arm. My missing pillow case. My full-fat ice cream. And I think someday I’ll be ok with that.